
Trying to decide between the Xacti CG10 and the Waterproof E2?
Read on.
I was trying to decide between the Sanyo Xacti VPC-CG10 and the E2. The CG-10 simulates HD and this camera does not. The E2 is what I bought, for a couple of reasons. My last cheaper pistol-grip cam was a Aiptek G0-HD and it lasted about 13 months. Why? I remember shooting some video outside and it started to rain, I thought it was light rain and continued to shoot. When I got home, the video markedly degraded and lost color (flickered green). It went in the trash literally. I fear the CG10 would suffer the same fate. The CG10 has a 10 megapixel CMOS chip and the E2 has a "8" so there's some loss of video and still image quality. But, you know I shoot mostly in the "2" range anyway so 8 megapixels is fine for me. Do I ever intend to dip this in water? No. Not the pool, not the ocean, not anything. But, I think it will do fine if I ever get caught in the rain. As for widescreen - no simulated HD here. The camera does go up to 60 fps, but again I would rarely use it and it is nice to know the E2 can do it. Did find extremely low light video was too dark. I know you are reading this everywhere, but until you see it the low light thing will be a problem. You can increase your aperture to 3.5 and don't zoom in too much in low light scenes.
Yes, the optics are only X 5 zoom and lots of reviewers knock this. WHY?? YOU ONLY ARE PAYING ABOUT $200 for this camera! Get real, a lens alone can easily contribute up to 50% of the manufacturing cost. Up the zoom and the $200 tag goes away. I think you get a good bang for the buck. This is my second "economical" camera, I think it is a good deal.
Another thing with the CG10 is it generates simulated High Def files. I always had trouble editing these. It is getting better, now some of the editors do it. My computer would choke (even though it was dual core). Also, HD files take up a lot of space. I like the smaller 640X480 files produced by the E2. This is easier to edit. If you want to win an Oscar for best photography, don't buy the E2. If you want to shoot video and see reasonably clear quality video for the informal amateur videographer, this is a great grab and go camera.
HD files online, really how often do you totally give up and just play the regular resolution? ALWAYS, youtube files stutter or stop altogether. HD files are overblown in terms of utility. Would I like them in my camera? Sure, but the fact is they pose some problems in editing, take a long time to upload, and when they play on line we still only see them in 1/4 screen.
BIGGEST PROBLEMS - come on Sanyo, let us do battery in-camera charging. Get real. Do away with the proprietary USB cable. Using the "OK" button, should be more functional - let it do directional input in the menu instead of pressing the outside ring. Really needs a lens cap, would rather have that over the "cheap" camera case. Don't ever hire the same person to write that manual again. Some things just aren't clear. You are getting better though over the E1 manual from what I hear, but Sanyo just hire someone that understands the US customer! Can't we have a bit longer batter (like 1000 mAh rather than the 720) or even a second li-ion battery in the box? Again, so I will write it twice Sanyo, please in-camera charging!
BIGGEST POSITIVES - light weight, water-repellent (not proof "as eventually in the fine print" you will see a need to check the seals yearly). Go ahead, dip it in water if you want, I am not. This camera is great for outdoors, lots of sunlight (although LCD is poorly viewable in the sun). MP4 file compression is great. I like 5X zoom, face tracking, and point focusing. Motor is really quiet when zooming and you don't get the loud noise on video of the hum. Stereo sound is fantastic. Face tracking is a plus! Nice you can swap from "complex every detail" menu to a "simple" one.
BOTTOM LINE - This is for outdoor fun - camping, snow skiing, hiking, & a little rain, and a quick and light camera. If I give get a 2 year life span then I will be happy. I am sure the CG10 is a great camera too, not taking pot shots at it here. It is just the E2 is probably in the dying breed of 640x480 cameras and until we advance a bit in support online and in storage space - I'll stick with normal definition awhile.
Get more detail about
Sanyo Xacti VPC-E2 Digital Camcorder and 8 MP Digital Camera (Blue).